A Natural Disaster
Thankfully, a note of sanity in a sea of ill-informed blather: "FEMA is reporting that 90% of the New Orleans infrastructure is gone. 300,000 people stayed behind, not heeding warnings to evacuate. To blame the resultant chaos in the immediate aftermath on the Bushies is to argue implicitly that you expect your federal government to act as a surrogate parent, not as a smaller, hands off federal entity that defers power to local governments . . . to be clear: I’m not saying the feds shouldn’t doing everything they can to help; but what I am saying is that too many people seem to think they have magic powers, and that their failure to have all the problems in New Orleans solved by now—in the absence of an infrastructure on which to operate—is an institutional failing rather than an obvious certainty of terrestrial physics."
I've been a little surprised at the haste with which analysts and pundits have rushed in to criticize the federal government and federal relief agencies. This was a natural disaster, not some game of dodgeball -- roads have been washed away, the main interstate into New Orleans is shattered, and the outlying areas have also been severely damaged and need attention, as well. There's this strange obsession about New Orleans only, as if the storm occurred locally and nobody else needs help -- relief agencies are spread across Alabama, Mississippi and Louisiana, but the news agencies are only reporting on New Orleans, which makes it seems as though the delay in getting people out of that particular city is just sluggishness on the part of the state and federal agencies rather than the sad fact that these agencies are completely overwhelmed by the magnitude of the damage to the entire Gulf Coast region (not just New Orleans).
And I am so frickin' pissed at the Congressional Black Caucus. To suggest (no, scratch that -- they came right out and said it!) that the people in New Orleans are being left to die because they are poor and black is a slap in the face to the several hundred thousand people who are already on the scene helping, and to the rest of the American population who have presently donated tens of millions of dollars in financial aid, food, clothing, water and medical supplies, and this is only days after the hurricane.
For all those who insist that nothing was done in preparation for the disaster, and that nobody thought in advance about what would be needed, here are excerpts from an August 29th AP article:
"As the Category 4 storm surged ashore just east of New Orleans on Monday, FEMA had medical teams, rescue squads and groups prepared to supply food and water poised in a semicircle around the city, said agency Director Michael Brown . . . Brown, in a telephone interview with The Associated Press, said the evacuation of the city and the general emergency response were working as planned in an exercise a year ago. "I was impressed with the evacuation, once it was ordered it was very smooth," he said.
"The American Red Cross said it had about 200,000 volunteers mobilized for the hurricane, the "largest single mobilization that we've done for any single natural disaster," said spokesman Bradley Hague . . . Baby formula from the Agriculture Department, communications equipment and medical teams from the Defense Department and generators, water and ice from the Federal Emergency Management Agency are among the assistance ready for the victims of Hurricane Katrina.
"Also, the Forest Service, which is part of the department, has an incident command team that will coordinate with FEMA and the Red Cross."
There was a lot of preparedness on the part of federal agencies and relief organizations, yet despite the frequent statements that the magnitude of the disaster simply overwhelmed the organizations set in place to provide relief, the news media and race obsessed spokespeople insist that there was nothing in place, no relief intended and that poor black people were simply left to die, conveniently ignoring the fact that FEMA and other organizations had trained for this event, had people in place to help, but were horrifically outdone by the storm and its aftermath
Much of the south is suffering a blackout that won't end for weeks, with power outages across the entire state of Alabama, plus roads and bridges made impassable due to flooding and debris. Biloxi, Mississippi is near decimated, and Mississippi in general has suffered enormous damage -- Interstate 10 has been made impassable, seawalls have been washed away, numerous towns along the coast were heavily damaged (if not outright destroyed) and will take years to rebuild, the dead are still being counted and there are presently over 12,000 people housed in temporary shelters with nowhere left to return to.
So what's up with the New Orleans obsessed race-mongers? The aftermath of Hurricane Katrina has nothing to do with race or politics, and everything to do with a disaster that has engulfed the southern coastal region. To focus purely on the plight of black people in New Orleans, while completely ignoring the very real suffering and misery of everyone else in the surrounding regions, is far more racist and bigoted than anything the Bush Administration could ever be accused of. Are poor black people in New Orleans the only ones who matter to the likes of Jesse Jackson? Let's have a little less race-baiting, blame-gaming and 20/20 hindsight, a lot less obsession over New Orleans as the only area of any concern whatsoever, and way more perspective on the overwhelming geographical magnitude of the hurricane's effect.
News flash for the media, the raving left and the extremists on the right -- Katrina didn't just damage New Orleans, and the political beliefs or skin color of the people affected shouldn't mean squat. We have a lot of work to do as a country, and a lot of damage across Mississippi, Alabama and Louisiana to repair. Let's knock off the political posturing and blame-flailing and get down to actually helping people rebuild their towns, cities and lives.
I've personally recommended Americares in a previous post, which is delivering hundreds of thousands of dollars of antibiotics to the area, as well as truckloads of bottled water, but I also hear that The Salvation Army is doing terrific work.
ADDENDUM:
This is now the second major disaster that has happened under one president. I well think that George W. Bush may be remembered historically for the challenge of dealing with both a national security disaster and a horrific natural disaster, not to mention major international turmoil. How Katrina plays out in the next several years, regarding economic effects and the rebuilding of the Gulf Coast, will make or break his legacy. Here's hoping that it makes it, not because it personally concerns me as to whether President Bush is remembered fondly by historians, but because a positive legacy would mean that the United States citizenry were able to take a terrible natural disaster in stride, and come out swinging.
That's my hope.
ADDENDUM 2:
Remember when, during the Cold War, we had Civil Defense stockpiles around the country? Water barrels, food rations, medical kits, sanitation kits, radiation kits and other supplies -- there were also more than nineteen hundred 200 bed mobile hospitals stored around the country, similar to an army field hospital. With natural disasters, such as forest fires, floods, earthquakes and hurricanes, as well as recent fears of biological and more standard forms of terrorism, it only seems like common sense to begin establishing Civil Defense stockpiles again so that we have extra resources more readily available in times of regional or national crisis.
The American Red Cross alone had an estimated 200,000 people ready around the New Orleans area with food, water and other supplies, but they were completely overwhelmed. It would have helped greatly if the country had had stockpiles of additional and necessary food, water and emergency supplies, plus mobile hospitals, already existing in key geographical areas that could have been readily accessed and trucked (or helicoptered) in.
I'm just sayin . . .
UPDATE:
As long as New Orleans Mayor Ray Nagin is taking deflective potshots at the Federal Government for allegedly "not doing enough," I thought I'd pass on this photo, linked on The Drudge Report, which shows an entire lot full of school buses engulfed in flood waters. The caption on Drudge reads: "WHY DIDN'T YOU DEPLOY THE BUSES DURING THE MANDATORY EVACUATION, MAYOR?"
Why, indeed. For a man who's "blasting" President Bush and allegedly "spitting fury" at the White House, Ray Nagin certainly has a lot of responsibility to shoulder for the vast amount of people still left in New Orleans when Katrina hit, and I believe that this is why he's yelling so loudly to the press about the Federal Government -- "No, don't look at that flooded parking lot full of empty buses that could have been used to evacuate the population, listen to what I have to say about George Bush . . ."



Comments
Thank you for saying this. You do a much better job of it than I can.
Posted by: cj69collins | September 2, 2005 2:53 PM
I could not agree with this article any more. It has hit the nail on the head as to the problems with the politicalization and race baiting of the whole relief effort. Peolpe are dying and in need of of help and prayers, not hearing more and more about how the government has failed them. Our country is being pulled apart by all of this slanted, narrow viewed, me me meism that our polticions giving us in an attempt to be remembered for the next election cycle.
Posted by: Kenneth Albin | September 2, 2005 8:33 PM
I really wish I could share your surprise at the finger-pointing contest between the Mayor of N.O. and the crybaby Governor of Louisiana, but 60 years of American socialism have reduced U.S. to a predominatly lazy-whiner country: The willful invalids want their freebees, and they don't mean later or maybe. Not surprisingly, it's the same lot who've ALWAYS wanted nothing else! There's everything right about helping those who cannot help themselves, and everything wrong about carrying goldbrickers and turning the safety nets into hammocks for them.
Posted by: Ted | September 3, 2005 3:25 AM
I blogged about this already (I waited until today, when I couldn't take it anymore), but I just have to say that I have no respect for the mayor of New Orleans, or the governor of Louisiana. It's the "entitlement" mentality that caused both of them to shirk their emergency planning responsibilities and wait for FEMA to swoop in and save them from themselves. Unfortunately, thousands of citizens of New Orleans had to suffer because of their idiocy. I just hope that someone is starting the impeachment proceedings...
Posted by: Phillip | September 4, 2005 6:18 PM
This tragedy is being sucked into the hell-hole of partisan Democrat politics. I'm a paleo-conservative, and I'm not defending Bush2, whose presidency is more like Mexican Vincente Fox then it is like Ronald Reagan. I agree that if Bush2 wasn't distracted by some lunatic military crusade in the middle east, or off on some political junket trying to repair the damage his neo-con war has inflicted on his polls numbers things might have been different.
But the sight of the Creole mixed race bastard MAYOR of New Orleans blaming the federal government for the problems is just plain so sickening that even I---a "Bush-basher" must cry "Foul"!
Here are the New Orleans school buses that could have evacuated the city before the hurricane hit, sitting around in nice, neat, flooded, useless rows afterwards. There are approximately 200 buses in this picture alone, and there are clearly more that are beyond the margins of the photo. If each one of the 200 could carry 60 people, that's 12,000 who could have been ferried out on each trip to, say, Baton Rouge on higher ground just 75 miles away. (Source: Yahoo News, 9/1/05 http://news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=story&u=/050901/480/flpc21109012015
Also great article by Steve Sailor, American Conservative Columnist in VDARE on the political culture of New Orleans.
SEE: READ: Racial Reality And The New Orleans Nightmare Steve Sailor/Vdare/September 3 2005
http://www.vdare.com/sailer/050903_new_orleans.htm
Posted by: David | September 4, 2005 10:18 PM
This article needs to be published... run in every major newspaper and read on every tv and radio station in the country. There will still be people who refuse to listen, who must have someone (other than themselves) to blame, but at the very least SOMEONE would be telling the WHOLE TRUTH of the story! Thank you for your eloquence, your eye for honesty, and the BS filter that have enabled you to see through the potshots and political back peddling of the news media and Mayor Nagin.
Posted by: Heather | September 5, 2005 1:54 AM
To true, Homocon. I especially liked vampire book author Anne Rice's criticism of the situation in the NYT. Here's the summary:
"I lived in New Orleans and would help out but now have a mansion in La Jolla, George W. Bush hates anyone Black and poor, and buy my new book available in hardcover from Knopf this November."
Posted by: Scott | September 5, 2005 10:10 AM
The federal government and FEMA are ancillary to the state and local governmaents in times of disaster. FEMA does not have an off-the-shelf plan of action for every possible cataclysm in every possible locale in the US. The state and local gov'ts formulate plans and FEMA assists. THE WAS NO VIABLE PLAN IN NOLA. The CITY govt sent the thousands of stranded citizens to the Superdome. What did they find? Not one pint of water, no medicine, no food and the city and local school buses under 15-20 feet of water. There entire gulf coast from NOLA damn near to Tampa is whacked. By what omniscience were the army and national guard commanders to know where to deploy before the erratic storm hit? Sunday night, Aaron Brown was smirking that the storm had missed NOLA. The sight of the dems gleefully gearing up to hang this one on the president is sickening. The culpability lies with that smart-ass mayor and that moron of a governor. NOLA is the most corrupt city in the US. When the disaster relief and rebuilding dollars start to flow into the city, you will see some REAL looting.
Posted by: ben | September 5, 2005 1:31 PM
not allowing comments on your fred phelps post anymore, eh?
did you know ted bundy was a republican?
my point is that this whole argument is silly. for you to make a cheap shot saying that democrats hate gays, just b/c a hateful homophobe like phelps says he is a democrat, shows your true colors.
you don't care about the truth, obviously. you like big headlines. and you did well at that. too bad it prevents anyone from actually taking you seriously.
you should be ashamed.
if you really are gay, you're doing every gay american a disservice by printing such outrageous lies as your headline states.
Posted by: lefty | September 5, 2005 1:46 PM
What galls me is the fact that we've only seen the shot of a parking lot full of school buses flooded once. What the hell was Nagin doing with those buses or rather not doing? He should have had those things so full of his citizens that when the doors opened upon arrival at some place outside the storm path, people exploded out of them like a fire hose. But we strangely don't hear anything about why he didn't utilize his own infrastructure to evacuate people before the disaster, just his hysterical ranting about how little was done after.
Posted by: Chuck | September 6, 2005 2:48 AM
Wow. I appreciate that you've cobbled all this information together. It was insightful. But I respectfully disagree with your assessment of the Bush legacy. I'm very underwhelmed by, well, everything he does. I've totally lost my faith in him. Not that there is anyone better. Maybe McCain, but what good is second guessing? Thanks for putting this together for all of us to read.
Posted by: David | September 6, 2005 5:53 PM